Suggested remit: To appraise the clinical and cost effectiveness of remdesivir, tocilizumab, casirivimab and imdevimab, baricitinib, sotrovimab, molnupiravir, anakinra, lenzilumab and nirmatrelvir and ritonavir within their proposed marketing authorisations for treating people with symptomatic coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).
Status In progress
Technology type Medicine
Decision Selected
Process MTA
ID number 4038

Project Team

Project lead Louise Jafferally

Email enquiries

External Assessment Group School of Health and Related Research (ScHARR), University of Sheffield


Companies sponsors Eli and Lilly (baricitinib)
  Gilead Sciences (remdesivir)
  GlaxoSmithKline (sotrovimab)
  Humanigen (lenzilumab)
  Merck Sharp & Dohme (molnupiravir)
  Pfizer (nirmatrelvir and ritonavir)
  Roche (casirivimab, imdevimab and tocilizumab)
  Swedish Orphan Biovitrum (anakinra)
Others Department of Health and Social Care
  NHS England
  Welsh Government
Patient carer groups Action for Pulmonary Fibrosis
  Anthony Nolan
  Blood Cancer UK
  Diabetes UK
  Immunodeficiency UK
  Leukaemia Care
  Long Covid Kids
  Long Covid Support
  Lupus UK
  MS Society
  Multiple Sclerosis Trust
  Myeloma UK
  Sarcoidosis UK
  Thrombosis UK
Professional groups Association of Cancer Physicians
  British Infection Association
  British Society for Allergy & Clinical Immunology
  British Society for Immunology
  British Thoracic Society
  British Transplant Society
  Cancer Research UK
  Faculty of Pharmaceutical Medicine
  Royal College of Physicians
  UK Clinical Pharmacy Association
  UK Kidney Association
  UK Renal Pharmacy Group
Associated public health groups None
General commentators All Wales Therapeutics and Toxicology Centre
  British National Formulary
  Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for Northern Ireland
  Healthcare Improvement Scotland
  Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency
  Scottish Medicines Consortium
  Welsh Health Specialised Services Committee
Relevant research groups Long Covid Research Initiative


Key events during the development of the guidance:

Date Update
19 April 2022 Invitation to participate
14 April 2022 Stakeholder Information Meeting
23 March 2022 In progress. Invitation to Stakeholder Information Meeting issued.
15 March 2022 Update and next steps following the scoping exercise for the proposed topic COVID-19 therapeutics ID4038. We carefully considered the comments from all stakeholders and were pleased that there was broad support for NICE to carry out an evaluation of the clinical and cost-effectiveness of these treatments. However, a common theme from the comments was that timing was crucial and that right now is perhaps not the right time to start a Multiple Technology Appraisal (MTA). We acknowledge the concerns around timing, but as some stakeholders highlighted, an MTA can take more than 11 months to reach recommendations. NICE would not be able to respond quickly using its standard MTA approach if it becomes clear that guidance is required. Taking this all into account, we will be resequencing the steps of an MTA in order to start the academic work to assess the clinical evidence and develop an economic model now, without formally starting an evaluation. Developing and validating an economic model first will enable us to be much more responsive and undertake the evaluation stage and produce recommendations in a much shorter time frame. We will not therefore be inviting stakeholder submissions at this stage. But we do intend for stakeholders to be involved in this phase of work. Firstly, we plan to hold a stakeholder information meeting in approximately 4-6 weeks time to give more information about what we are planning and for the academic group to present a protocol for how they will approach the work. Once the academic group has built the model and produced a report there will be a stakeholder consultation. The approach outlined is broadly supported by NHS England, the Department of Health and Social Care and the bodies responsible for HTA in other parts of the UK.
06 January 2022 - 03 February 2022 Consultation on suggested remit, draft scope and provisional stakeholder list of consultees and commentators
25 January 2022 (10:00) Scoping workshop

For further information on our processes and methods, please see our CHTE processes and methods manual