Evidence suggested that chemotherapy regimens that contain platinums and those that do not may have similar impacts on overall survival and progression-free survival in people with triple-negative advanced breast cancer.
The committee highlighted that the evidence suggested an increased risk of some side effects (for example, neutropenia, and nausea or vomiting) with chemotherapy regimens including platinums, compared with those without. However, the evidence was very uncertain due to the studies being at a high risk of bias, and there being a large variation in results between studies for some outcomes. It also included a variety of different comparator drugs, all of which have different side-effect profiles, but only side effects most commonly expected with platinums were reported in the studies. Because of this and the evidence for overall survival and progression-free survival, the committee agreed that they were unable to recommend using platinum-based chemotherapy over non-platinum chemotherapy for people with triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC). However, they noted that the choice of the type of chemotherapy or other SACT is a complex one that needs to be tailored to the individual and agreed that for some people with triple-negative advanced breast cancer platinum-based chemotherapy would be a suitable option.
The committee recognised that clinical practice has changed greatly over time and that a single sequence of chemotherapies for everyone with advanced breast cancer is no longer relevant. However, they noted that chemotherapies in the 2009 recommendation are still in use, and they agreed to add carboplatin to this list of potential options for TNBC. They agreed that the 2009 recommendation on offering systemic sequential chemotherapy also remained relevant.
The committee were unable to recommend a different chemotherapy regimen for people who have TNBC with, or without, germline BRCA1 or BRCA2 pathogenic variants because of the limited number of included trials and small number of participants in them. Therefore, they drafted a recommendation for research on platinum-containing chemotherapy regimens to try to fill these gaps in the evidence base.
Full details of the evidence and the committee's discussion are in evidence review A: platinum-containing chemotherapy regimens.